Polenta with Mushrooms and Gravy

by Estee Raviv
Two patties of polenta with a layer of cooked mushrooms in between and drenched in pale gravy with dill pieces and pepper on a white plate with a yellow napkin on the side.

Polenta is a dish that is popular in Italy and Romania. It is made out of corn grits, so it is naturally gluten-free. I grew up eating it since my mom is Romanian and she used to make it for us all the time. The mushrooms and gravy is inspired by a popular “wedding dish” from the ’70s and ’80s in Israel. I thought this would be perfect for Thanksgiving. This dish is the ultimate comfort food!


Mushroom Filling:
1 tablespoon olive oil
1 onion, chopped
3 cloves of garlic, minced (or you can use garlic confit)
Mini Bella mushrooms or mushrooms of your choice, chopped 24 oz / 680 g

3 tablespoons olive oil
3 tablespoons gluten-free oat flour or regular flour
1 1/2 cups water
1/2 tablespoon vegetable base
Pinch of pepper
Pinch of salt if needed
Substitution: you can use vegetable broth instead of the water and vegetable base.

4 cups of water
1 teaspoon salt
1 cup polenta
1 tablespoon nutritional yeast
1 tablespoon olive oil


Mushroom Filling:
Take a wide pan and add olive oil, onion, salt, and pepper. Sauté on medium heat for a couple of minutes, and then add garlic. Sauté for another minute and add the mushrooms. Sauté until all the liquids have evaporated. Set aside.

Take a wide stainless steel pan and add olive oil and flour. Use a whisk to mix and cook the flour. You want bubbles to form. In a glass measuring cup, mix the water with the vegetable base to create a vegetable broth. Cook the flour/olive oil for a minute and then add the vegetable broth. Mix with a whisk until it thickens. Add pepper and salt if needed. Set aside.

Bring a pot of water to a boil. Add salt, and polenta, and whisk constantly until it thickens. It will take a couple of minutes. Then add nutritional yeast and olive oil, keep whisking and turn the heat off. Set aside.

Assemble the dish:

Take 10 ramekins or individual glass dishes.

While the polenta is still hot, pour about a tablespoon and a half into the ramekins. Then, on top of that, pour about a tablespoon and a half of the mushroom filling, and lastly, another tablespoon and a half of the polenta. Each layer should take up approximately a third of the ramekin until it is filled to the top.

Let it cool down and set. The polenta will harden.

Serving suggestion:

Using a knife, release the sides of each ramekin. Turn the ramekin upside down onto a dinner plate to release the polenta onto the dish. (See the pictures below for a demonstration of how to remove the polenta from the ramekin). Now you have a nice round polenta on the plate. Take the gravy and pour some over the polenta. Sprinkle some greens on top and serve warm.


Tip: For easiest assembly, first prepare the mushroom filling, then the gravy, and lastly the polenta. Additionally, you can prepare the gravy and the mushroom filling the day before, so you don’t need to prepare everything in one day.

This recipe makes 10 appetizers size servings or 5 main size servings.

For more of Estee’s recipes, go to https://www.esteeskitchen.com/.

To follow Estee on social media:
https://www.facebook.com/FromEsteesKitchen/; https://www.instagram.com/fromesteeskitchen/

Apple Nachos for Tu BiShvat This super easy plate of Apple Nachos is perfect for Tu BiShvat! You can add many of The Seven... Appetizer
A black bowl featuring barley, kalamata olives, and lots of green herbs.
Biblical Barley and Herb Salad These days, most people consider barley—if they consider it at all—as something wintery, perhaps sharing space with mushrooms in... Side
Seven Species Muffins These muffins are a great not-too-sweet treat for your Tu BiShvat celebration as they contain all seven species mentioned... Breakfast
Tu BiShvat Vegan Challah with Dried Fruit This vegan braided challah is filled with dried fruit like dates, figs, apricots, toasted walnut and orange zest. It... Appetizer
Vegan Carrot & Sweet Potato Latkes This latke combines Jewish tradition with Indian, as it is inspired by the Indian pakora snack. Appetizer
Golden Tumeric Cake This vegan Golden Turmeric Cake is moist, just dense enough, and has the perfect sweetness level. It has a... Dessert
A large white bowl with bulgur, tomatoes, cucumber, and parsley mixed together next to a black napkin with a white leaf design.
Tabouli / Tabbouleh This super fresh herb and bulgur Mediterranean salad is the perfect snack, side, or even meal when paired with... Side
Vegan Gondi (Chickpea Dumpling Stew) Vegan Gondi, Chickpea Dumpling Stew, is a Persian-Jewish Shabbat hors d’oeuvres. It is typically made with chicken, however, it... Appetizer
A white ceramic baking dish filled with cooked carrots, sweet potatoes, and dried fruit on a gold floral tablecloth surrounded by white plates and silver forks.
Carrot and Sweet Potato Tzimmes You need not wait for a holiday—or be Jewish—to enjoy carrot and sweet potato tzimmes. It’s a festive dish... Side
A small gray bowl of orange vegetables and grains on top of a large gray plate with a red napkin and bronze fork.
Vegan Cholent Vegan cholent might seem like a stretch, but why not? With seitan or other plant-based beefy protein standing in... Main
A black bowl featuring brown seitan stew. A yellow napkin and silver spoon are situated in the background on a dark wood table.
Seitan Porcini Stew This is a recipe that not only comforts you on a cold winter’s night, it makes you look forward... Main
A square brown platter topped with sufganiyot--raspberry jelly filled donuts topped with powdered sugar, all on a red tablecloth.
Mayim Bialik’s Sufganiyot A lovely, easy and fun to make treat for Chanukah! These doughnuts are best when served immediately, but they... Dessert